Sony BMG Rootkit Fallout

Who has the right to control your PC?

“A personal computer is called a personal computer because it’s yours,” said Andrew Moss, Microsoft’s senior director of technical policy. “Anything that runs on that computer, you should have control over.”

Sounds simple, but it’s not.

[…] The controversy over Sony’s copy protection highlights two ideas of property that are clashing as the technology and entertainment worlds converge.

Record labels and movie studios have complained bitterly over the last few years that their intellectual property rights in films, music and games are routinely undermined by people burning copies of discs or DVDs, or trading files online. […]

[…] But if some computer owners have shown a lack of respect for intellectual property rights, Sony’s invasive content protection tools displayed a similarly tone-deaf attitude to consumers’ sense of ownership over their own PCs, critics say.

“If you wanted to take something from the lesson of Sony’s rootkit, it should be that people want their demands for respect and autonomy to be taken more seriously,” said Julie Cohen, a Georgetown University law professor who has written extensively on the intersection of property and technology.

See also Slashdot’s President of RIAA Says Sony-BMG Did Nothing Wrong and Piece of Tape Defeats Sony DRM and Gartner’s Sony BMG DRM a Public-Relations and Technology Failure