March 29, 2005

ZDNet’s (and Other’s) Coverage of Grokster Arguments [12:49 pm]

Supreme Court takes hard look at P2P (CNet version)

In their questions, the justices were critical of the entertainment industry’s proposal, which would hold companies “predominantly” supported by piracy liable for copyright infringement. However, they showed little sympathy for the file-swapping companies’ business model.

“What you are suggesting is unlawful expropriation of property as a kind of start-up capital,” said Justice Anthony Kennedy. “From an economic standpoint and legal standpoint, that sounds wrong.”

Donna points to SCOTUS Blog’s report: Court conflicted over file-swapping

Also: learn about what it is to wait in line to get into a hot Supreme Court session from these links at BoingBoing

Later: The Washington Post article seems to be carving out the scope of the compromise — Supreme Court Hears File-Sharing Case (some audio)

Justice Stephen G. Breyer said the same software that can be used to steal copyrighted materials offered at least conceptually “some really excellent uses” that are legal.

Justice Antonin Scalia maintained that a ruling for entertainment companies could mean that if “I’m a new inventor, I’m going to get sued right away.”

While seeming leery of allowing lawsuits, the court also appeared deeply troubled by efforts of the companies that manufacture so-called file-sharing software to encourage Internet piracy and profit from it.

Slashdot: Supreme Court Takes Hard Look at P2P

EFF DeepLinks: Justices Ask the Right Questions in MGM v. Grokster and Grokster: From the Courthouse Steps

Missed the (wholly unbiased <G>) LATimes editorial this morning: California’s Civil War

None of this is to say that peer-to-peer systems like Grokster and Morpheus aren’t allowing consumers to shoplift digitally, victimizing creative artists and their corporate distributors. But there are plenty of non- infringing uses for file-sharing systems, and the justices today will probably quibble about how much legitimate copying is enough to save the likes of Grokster.

Wired News’ File Sharing Has Supreme Moment

permalink to just this entry

September 2014
S M T W T F S
« Jun    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930  
posts

0.117 || Powered by WordPress