August 27, 2013

Larry’s Picked An Interesting Fight [8:59 pm]

Online lecture prompts legal fight on copyright: Harvard’s Lessig, Australian record company battle over use of song [pdf]

But that is exactly what Australian record company Liberation Music did when it threatened to sue Lessig, a leading scholar of Internet law and an advocate for fewer copyright restrictions, for allegedly violating its rights by using music from the hit song “Lisztomania” by French pop band Phoenix during a lecture.

Liberation Music claimed to own the license for the 2009 song, which became so popular that fans, college students, and choruses from around the world made their own dance videos to the music and posted them on YouTube, creating something of a global Internet phenomenon.

Lessig used the phenomenon and excerpts from the dance videos in a 2010 lecture that he recorded and also posted to YouTube, prompting the legal warning from Liberation Music.

Now, Lessig is fighting back with his own legal action.

So, an interesting challenge, in that there is, first, the overall “fair use” doctrine — a nice idea, but one that means that a definitive finding of fair use, should there be a disagreement, requires an adjudicated review; second, there is legislation ensuring fair use in academic use, thus taking some of the transactional costs of adjudication off the table; and, third, there is an open question on what happens when one digitizes and distributes academic material containing copyrighted materials whose use in that context would ordinarily be considered to be covered under fair use.

It’s been a challenge for academic institutions moving instruction online, and should be a great fight, since Larry has been passionate about this.

Finally, it’s worth thinking about the distinctions between this approach to tackling copyright injustices and that of Aaron Swartz.

Later: When even John Sununu takes time out from using his guest Tea-Party-rousing-columnist role at the Boston Globe to agree with Larry, you know that Liberation Music has really stepped in it: Music dinosaurs pick a bad fight [pdf]

permalink to just this entry

August 4, 2013

I Enjoyed This Immensely [9:13 pm]

From David Carr, calling a spade a spade: Self-Serving War of Words by 2 Giants in Television [pdf]:

We know that you are fighting over lucre, not our inalienable rights as cable consumers. Pretending that you are fighting on our behalf rather than in the interests of your shareholders and executives is infantilizing and unbecoming. CBS is coming off another record year, Time Warner Cable’s stock is storming along, and the fight over retransmission fees is about how the pie is sliced, nothing more.

permalink to just this entry

August 2013
S M T W T F S
« Jun   Sep »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
posts

0.161 || Powered by WordPress