Intellectual "Property" in the Digital Age
Frank Field
Links Home : Copyright : Security Systems Standards & Certification Act (SSSCA) : Consumer Broadband and Digital Television Promotion Act (CBDTPA)

Suggest a link for this category
How the SSSCA was submitted to the Senate (S.2084) - March 21, 2002.


-REC A Fence Too Far
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 16th May 2002]; Roger Parloff; May 16, 2002. "Though my guess is that creators can adequately protect their digital wares without legislation of this sort, if events should prove me wrong, the Hollings legislation should still be defeated. If controlling digital property requires government intervention on this scale, then there should be no such control. Digital technology will have rebuffed the legal system's attempts to tame it, anti-protectionists will have won the war, and it will be time for protectionists like me to raise the white flag. We can't imperil everyone's freedom and prosperity in a quixotic quest. The game has to end somewhere."
It appears that has made this article hard to find - I'll keep working on it.....
Rate this:
-REC Another Punch for Copy Protection
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 28th Mar 2002]; Declan McCullagh; March 28, 2002. "A Democratic legislator from the home of the Walt Disney and Warner Bros. studios is drafting a bill to reduce online piracy by implanting strict copy controls in digital devices....
On Wednesday, Rep. Adam Schiff of Burbank, California, circulated a letter on Capitol Hill seeking co-sponsors for his legislation, which he said would follow the same approach as the Consumer Broadband and Digital Television Promotion Act (CBDTPA) in the Senate." The battle heats up - it will be interesting to see the Republican response. Slashdot discussion: CBDTPA Finds A Champion in the House
Rate this:
-REC Battle royale over piracy
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 29th Apr 2002]

ZDNet - Their summary page covering the emerging issues in piracy on the net and elswhere.
Rate this:
-REC Congressional Record; Introduction of S.2048
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]; p. 2269 et seq.; March 21, 2002. Referred to the Committee on Commerce, Science & Transportation (not Judiciary). You have to do the search, and I can't construct the cgi query for you. This takes you to a search page - specify Senator Fritz Hollings, the text 2048, and the date 03/21/2002 (The 107th Congress). You'll get two hits. The PDF version - This link embeds the Thomas query and is purported to always work.
Rate this:
-REC Democrats vs. New Media
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 30th Mar 2002]

Tech Central Station: Tech; Glenn Harlan Reynolds, March 27, 2002. A little more on the wedge issue - "If the Republicans have any sense, they'll be making an issue of this in the next elections, painting the Democrats as hypocrites who have sold out to Hollywood, and who are trying to reach, Big Brother-like, into the hearts of American televisions and computers. But even if they don't, a lot of Web denizens will be saying it, and it's likely to have a lot of resonance. Because it's true."
Rate this:
-REC Tech execs help Hollywood fight piracy
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 15th Jul 2002]

ZDNet News; John Borland; July 15, 2002. CNet version

Technology executives said Monday that they're ready to work with Hollywood to prevent piracy but they're concerned that studios' efforts could undermine file-swapping technology.

In a joint missive to studio chiefs, signed by Microsoft's Steve Ballmer, Intel's Craig Barrett, Dell Computer's Michael Dell and others, technology CEOs said they were ready to sit down with movie industry representatives to discuss anti-piracy issues--but only if the studios agree that technology can't solve all their problems.

With several conditions attached, the letter represented only a qualified olive branch extended toward the studios, which have criticized technology companies for turning a blind eye to Net piracy.

Rate this:
-REC Ted Waitt: Defender of downloads
[5 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 29th May 2002]

ZDNet News; Charles Cooper; May 29, 2002.

If he finds himself dining at Spago anytime soon, Gateway CEO Ted Waitt isn't likely to receive any bear hugs from the Hollywood moguls who favor this perennial Los Angeles hot spot.

That's because Gateway's chief executive officer finds himself on the other side of a bitter digital divide from the entertainment industry over the issue of digital music downloads. Throw in an opportunity for a grandstanding politician or two, and you have the makings of a grand donnybrook.

Rate this:
-REC The Voice of Hollywood Shows Signs of Cracking
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 29th Apr 2002]

Los Angeles Times; Edmund Sanders; April 29, 2002. "When an influential U.S. senator introduced legislation last month to help entertainment companies block unauthorized downloading of movies and music, the Motion Picture Assn. of America--the official voice of major Hollywood studios--dutifully presented a united front and endorsed the bill.
... Behind the scenes, however, the carefully crafted statement of support was the subject of painstaking negotiations, bickering and a flurry of tense meetings and conference calls by the companies' chief Washington lobbyists, who were anything but united. "
Rate this:
-REC U.S. prepares to invade your hard drive
[15 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 29th Mar 2002]

Salon; Paul Boutin; March 29, 2002. "A bill before Congress would mandate built-in copy-protection on all digital devices. But even technology experts who really want to protect intellectual property think it's a lousy idea."
Rate this:
-'This Is War'
[8 hits, 4 votes, Average Rating 4.25] [Added: 15th May 2002]; Devin Leonard; May 27, 2002. "Should the computer industry protect Hollywood from digital theft? The guns are drawn." This is an article that misses the point of the conflict, but certainly summarizes the depth of feeling on both sides.
Rate this:
-A Fence Too Far:Why government regulators must recognize the difference between a computer and a VCR
[5 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 7th May 2002]; Roger Parloff; April 29, 2002.
Rate this:
-Anti-Copy Bill Hits D.C.
[9 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 21st Mar 2002]; Declan McCullagh; March 21, 2002. Here we go. Slashdot discussion here: SSSCA Introduced in Senate with LOTS of links on this story as it breaks
Rate this:
-Anti-Copy Bill Slams Coders
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]; Declan McCullagh; MArch 22, 2002. "Legal experts said on Friday that the CBDTPA regulates nearly any program, in source or object code, that runs on a PC or anything else with a microprocessor.
That's not just Windows media players and their brethren, as you might expect. The CBDTPA's sweeping definition of "any hardware or software" includes word processors, spreadsheets, operating systems, compilers, programming languages -- all the way down to humble Unix utilities like "cp" and "cat."
"The definition will cover just about anything that runs on your computer -- except maybe the clock," said Tom Bell, a professor at Chapman University School of Law who teaches intellectual property law." A pretty bleak look, of course. But the start of a nasty debate, perhaps.
Rate this:
-Bill takes wrong approach on copyright piracy
[6 hits, 1 votes, Average Rating 4.00] [Added: 26th Mar 2002]; David Hayes of the Kansas City Star; March 26, 2002.
Rate this:
-Consumers squeezed in battle between Hollywood, Silicon Valley
[5 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 1st Jul 2002]

SFGate; Simon Avery, AP Wire; June 30, 2002.

For years, consumers and electronics manufacturers have had an unwritten agreement.

Shoppers keep spending billions of dollars to upgrade their gadgetry, knowing their investments will quickly become outdated.

In return, the makers of computers, TV accessories and audio devices keep innovating, bringing consumers greater value and selection.

But widespread piracy in the music and film industries is threatening to short-circuit that arrangement.

In an aggressive effort to protect their content, film studios and record labels have helped draft legislation that would require electronic equipment makers to build products that limit online distribution while preventing consumers from making multiple versions of copyrighted material.

Rate this:
-Content, tech industries debate digital copy protection
[8 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 13th Jun 2002]

InfoWorld; Cara Garretson; June 13, 2002.

Mix the thundering clash of two huge U.S. industries with the threat of government intervention and the potential for consumer rights violations, and what do you get? The debate over digital copy protection that is playing out in Hollywood, Silicon Valley and, most recently, Washington, D.C.

Following numerous congressional hearings on the issue over the past few months, public policy group the Cato Institute hosted a panel discussion here Wednesday morning on whether technological controls should be put in place to protect copyright digital content, such as music and movies, from illegal copying and distribution. As expected, representatives of the technology industry disagreed with content company executives over who is responsible for safeguarding digital works.

Rate this:
-Copy protection controversy hits Senate
[10 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]

ZDNet News; John Borland; MArch 22, 2002. "A controversial bill that would ultimately require computer and consumer-electronics companies to build copyright-protection technology into their products was finally introduced in the U.S. Senate on Thursday." With a little more background on Hollings rather complex position in re: broadband (he was part of the opposition to recent moves to deregulate it) and reader comments.
Rate this:
-Copyright [CBDTPA] Bill Universally Rejected
[5 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 10th Apr 2002]; April 10, 2002. An article is cited stating that the Judiciary Committee did not receive a single comment in favor of the CBDTPA. With community discussion.
Rate this:
-Digital copyright bill may dumb down the PC
[8 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 25th May 2002]

EE Times; Dickson Ross; May 24, 2002. 'Intel Corp. says PCs could be turned into “dumb terminals” if a bill on digital copyright now before the U.S. Congress is passed.' Some are not so sure that Intel is on the right side of this discussion, despite what this article says.
Rate this:
-Digital rights management no cure-all, execs say
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 6th Jun 2002]

InfoWorld; Cara Garretson; June 6, 2002.An interesting juxtaposition with the recent BPDG report.

DESPITE the promise of digital rights management (DRM) technology to protect copyright works, software executives on Wednesday told members of the U.S. House of Representatives there is no silver bullet to stopping Internet piracy.

The industry executives who testified before a Judiciary subcommittee on Courts, the Internet, and Intellectual Property, chaired by North Carolina Republican Howard Coble, also told the congressmen that the government should not mandate the use of such technology, as some proposed legislation has suggested.

Rate this:
-Does it take hardware to repel pirates?
[8 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]

ZDNet News; Robert Lemos; March 22, 2002. Microsoft steps into the fray - and not on a side that one would expect. '"Every single device has to be secure," said Darko Kirovski, a researcher studying watermarking and security technologies at Microsoft Research. "If one device is not secure, then this (digital content protection) doesn't work."' CPRM raises its head...again.
Rate this:
-DRM hardware law gets new life, new name
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]

The Register; Thomas C. Greene; March 22, 2002. A typically sardonic look: "A piece of legislation proposed by Hollywood sock puppet Sen. Fritz Hollings (Democrat, South Carolina) requiring all electronic devices to contain copy-protection has finally been introduced, after being renamed to sound like something positive."
Rate this:
-Everyone hates SSSCA, CBDPTA in comments to Senate Judiciary panel
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 23rd Mar 2002]; March 23, 2002. A community discussion.
Rate this:
-Gilmore On Hardware-Restricted Content
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 12th May 2002]

Slashdot; May 12, 2002. A discussion of a posting of a message by John Gilmore (EFF) on the CBDTPA and related legislation/regulation - focusing on why Intel should not "cave in" to the current push.
Rate this:
-Guard Copyrights, Don't Jail Innovation
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 6th May 2002]

Business Week; Alex Salkever; March 27, 2002. "Senator Hollings' call for hardware-embedded anticopying measures is the last thing consumers and the entertainment industry need "
Rate this:
-Hollings Howls Will Have To Wait
[5 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 30th Mar 2002]; Declan McCullagh; March 30, 2002. Sen. Leahy says "No way!" this year for the CBDTPA. Slashdot discussion: CBDTPA / SSSCA Won't Be Passed This Year, Say Leahy
Rate this:
-Hollings Press Release Upon Introduction of the CBDTPA
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 21st Mar 2002]

PoliTechBot; Declan McCullagh's Site - chilling text
Rate this:
-Howling Mad Over Hollings' Bill
[8 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 28th Mar 2002]; Brad King; March 28, 2002. "Millions of people have networked their stereos, computers and television sets to take relaxation to a new level, but a proposed law could make those networks useless." "Along with upsetting the 2 million people who have already purchased digital television sets, the bill also wipes away many of the legal uses people have become accustomed to, Petricone said. The CEA is also averse to adding taxes onto the cost of new devices that could be used to pay entertainment companies, something the Audio Home Recording Act forced on portable MP3 makers."
Rate this:
-More Details on the CBDTPA
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]; March 22, 2002. Links, comments, etc.
Rate this:
-MS denounces Hollywood DRM Jihad
[9 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 6th Jun 2002]

The Register; Thomas C. Greene; June 6, 2002. How's that for an inflammatory title?

Microsoft has come out against the schemes and dreams of the entertainment industry with a position essay criticizing any notion of the government's mandating technical standards for content protection as Hollywood wants.

The authors clearly have in mind proposed legislation by Fritz "Hollywood" Hollings (Democrat, South Carolina) originally called the Security Systems Standards and Certification Act (SSSCA), recently renamed the Consumer Broadband and Digital Television Promotion Act (CBDTPA) to conceal it's [sic] proscriptive anti-consumer, and anti-tech industry nature.

Rate this:
-Piracy-prevention bill sparks hot debate
[8 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 26th Mar 2002]

ZDNet News; Stefanie Olson; March 25, 2002. "Several government and industry leaders this weekend criticized proposed legislation that calls on hardware makers to help protect Hollywood's interests, saying lawmakers should not decide the tech industry's "winners and losers."
Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash.; Les Vadasz, president of Intel Capital; Mitch Kapor, chairman of the Open Source Applications Foundation; and Hilary Rosen, CEO of the Recording Industry Association of America, engaged in a lively, sometimes heated, debate on recently proposed government controls on digital media devices. They met Sunday in an opening panel discussion at PC Forum, an annual technology conference hosted by author and technology pundit Esther Dyson. "
Rate this:
-Protecting Creative Works in a Digital Age
[9 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]

Senate Judiciary Committee BBS. Fun to read in the wake of the CBDTPA - many comments
Rate this:
-Seeking Arguments Against the CBDTPA?
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 4th Apr 2002]; April 4, 2002. Some really good points are made in the comments, and some letters from Congresspersons are quoted.
Rate this:
-Senator Introduces Long-Awaited Digital Piracy Bill
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 21st Mar 2002]

New York Times; Reuters; March 21, 2002. "Co-sponsors include Republican Ted Stevens of Alaska, and Democrats Daniel Inouye of Hawaii, John Breaux of Louisiana, Bill Nelson of Florida, and Dianne Feinstein of California."
Rate this:
-Singing Cow To Attack CBDTPA
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 12th Apr 2002]; APril 11, 2002. Gateway is getting ready to take on the CDBTPA on the consumer front - links, commentary
Rate this:
-Tech on the defensive in piracy brawl
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 28th Mar 2002]

ZDNet News; John Borland; March 27, 2002. "It's not quite open warfare between Hollywood and Silicon Valley, but the peace talks aren't looking good.
... The next several months will be a critical test for technology companies navigating rocky political waters. They're relative newcomers, although powerful ones, to Washington inner circles. The entertainment industry, by contrast, has long been among the most generous donors to political campaigns, with influential lobbying forces.
Some insiders say big tech's political inexperience has already put the industry in catch-up mode. "
Rate this:
-The CBDTPA Site on PoliTechBot
[10 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 21st Mar 2002]

PoliTechBot - A collection of releases, etc. assembled by Declan McCullagh.
Rate this:
[6 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]

Electronic Frontier Foundataion
Rate this:
-What Hollings' Bill Would Do
[7 hits, 0 votes, Average Rating 0] [Added: 22nd Mar 2002]; Declan McCullagh; March 22, 2002. A primer on what the bill includes.
Rate this:
-White House Cool to Hollings' Act
[10 hits, 1 votes, Average Rating 0.00] [Added: 27th Apr 2002]; Declan McCullagh; April 27, 2002. "James Rogan , the Commerce Department's undersecretary for intellectual property, has expressed mild skepticism about a bill championed by Senate Commerce chairman Fritz Hollings (D-South Carolina)." slashdot discussion: Commerce Department Cool to CBDTPA
Rate this:

Digital IP Links Home | Search Links | New Links | Popular Links | Top Rated | Admin Login | Powered by ssLinks v1.22