| Intellectual Property and the US Government |
- Legislation - Copyright
- Constitutional Basis, US - US
Constitution, Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8;
- Text of US Copyright Laws; Title 17 USC
- Text of US Copyright Regulations; 35 CFR which govern
the operation of the US
Copyright Office; the US Copyright Office's
selected Internet links
- The
Sonny Bono Copyright Law Extension Act; worth noting in light of an
entertaining science fiction story by Spider Robinson - "Melancholy
Elephants" (in By
Any Other name - ISBN:0671319744 )- the perils of extending
copyright ownership into perpetuity
- Washington's
First State of the Union Address where he states:
The advancement of agriculture, commerce, and
manufactures by all proper means will not, I trust, need
recommendation; but I can not forbear intimating to you the expediency
of giving effectual encouragement as well to the introduction of new
and useful inventions from abroad as to the exertions of skill and
genius in producing them at home, and of facilitating the intercourse
between the distant parts of our country by a due attention to the
post-office and post-roads.
Nor am I less persuaded that you will agree with me in the opinion that
there is nothing which can better deserve your patronage than the
promotion of science and literature. Knowledge is in every country the
surest basis of public happiness. In one in which the measures of
government receive their impressions so immediately from the sense of
community as in ours it is proportionately essential.
- Thomas Jefferson has a related, almost lyrical, take (links to
Jeffersonian quotes:
It would be singular to admit a natural and even an
hereditary right to inventors... It would be curious... if an idea, the
fugitive fermentation of an individual brain, could, of natural right,
be claimed in exclusive and stable property. If nature has made any one
thing less susceptible than all others of exclusive property, it is the action of the thinking power called an idea, which
an individual may exclusively possess as long as he keeps it to
himself; but the moment it is divulged, it forces itself into the
possession of every one, and the receiver cannot dispossess himself of
it. Its peculiar character, too, is that no one possesses the less,
because every other possesses the whole of it. He who receives an idea
from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who
lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me.
That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe, for
the moral and mutual instruction of man, and improvement of his
condition, seems to have been peculiarly and benevolently designed by
nature, when she made them, like fire, expansible over all space,
without lessening their density in any point, and like the air in which
we breathe, move and have our physical being, incapable of confinement
or exclusive appropriation. Inventions then cannot, in nature, be a
subject of property. Society may give an exclusive right to the profits
arising from them, as an encouragement to men to pursue ideas which may
produce utility, but this may or may not be done, according to the will
and convenience of the society, without claim or complaint from
anybody... The exclusive right to invention [is] given not of natural
right, but for the benefit of society. --Thomas Jefferson to Isaac
McPherson, 1813. ME 13:333
- Under the provisions of the DMCA, the Copyright Office is
obliged to report on the effects of the new elements of copyright
introduced upon electronic commerce. This site gives the current status
of testimony submitted and ongoing responses - Joint
Study Required by Section 104 of the Digital Millenium Copyright Act
- The House Judiciary Committee's Subcommitte on Courts
& Intellectual Property has a WWW site with testimony
from recent hearings (back to 1995)
- Petitioning for rulemaking; for example RIAA
Petition to Copyright Office for Rulemaking and Arbitration, 11/29/00
- IP as "legislated right" to promote arts and sciences;
openess of ideas; basis for development, instead of requiring
re-invention of the wheel
- A Copyright
Timeline (not including DMCA - see below) from the ARL (Association
of Research Librarians) site; here's their entire
copyright compilation
- The UK Government's Intellectual
Property WWW Site (works sometimes); a *really* concise history
- A historical exposition of evolution of copyright, ending
with DMCA
(Association of Research Libraries summary site)? The EFFector's article on
DMCA
- The European Union is adopting a
copyright directive similar to the DMCA; here's a description
from the Register; here's the
Slashdot discussion
- A little JOKE on DMCA - Aliens Use DMCA to
Sue Air Force Over UFOs; humor from BBSpot
- The Consumer Project on
Technology has a section on
intellectual property; more specifically, here's their list of IP laws
worldwide
- The Copyright Website:
a site devoted to tracking some of the pending issues in the area of US
copyright; especially digital issues and the related performance topics.
- The Music Law
Offices of Michael P. McReady; the practice of music copyright
- The Practice of Music Copyrights - the Harry Fox Agency description
from the NMPA site
- A
Guide to Copyright for Music Librarians; a nice compedium
of related internet links
- Case Law of Copyright - An Evolving Construct
- One case on strict construction of IP; player piano case
- White-Smith
Music Publishing Company vs. Apollo Company ("The
Piano Roll Precedent", "Copyright
law always tied to technology of the time")
- A perspective on the Player Piano case for today; Copyright Goes
Old_School; Running for Cover; Glenn Otis Brown; The New Republic
online; July 27, 2000
- more general stuff on the law of copyright and technology
chasing; article
1, article
2
- Technology again and copying; Sony Betamax case
(from the Home Recording Rights WWW site)
- Speech
by Rep. Boucher (D-Va) on Fair Use and Digital Media
- doctrine of fair
use; photocopying, taping, etc.
- "Strange
Fixation: Bootleg Sound Recordings Enjoy the Benefits of Improving
Technology; Federal Communications Law Journal 46, 3; an article
from the mid-1990's that presages the Internet as the next generation
of bootleg challenges to the music industry
- "Revising
the Copyright Law for Electronic Publishing"; David Loundy; John
Marshall Journal of Computer and Information Law; Fall, 1995. More of his articles
- The Internet case
additions to Joyce, Patry, Leaffer & Jaszi's Copyright Law,
Fifth Edition
- Advisory Committee to
the Congressional Internet Caucus
- An extensive and thoughtful article on the ferment of
intellectual thought around IP and the digital economy; Are
Intellectual Property Rights a Digital Dilemma? Controversial Topics
and International Aspects; Henry M. Gladney; iMP: The Magazine on Information
Impacts; Feb 2000
- The National Academies have taken a look, too. A typical Executive
Summary, but it does cover the waterfront. The Digital Dilemma:
Intellectual Property in the Information Age; Committee on
Intellectual Property Rights and the Emerging Information
Infrastructure, National Research Council; National Academy Press;
2000.
- The Stanford Libraries Fair Use WWW site
- Economic Constructs - Rationale for Development of
Intellectual Property
- Enforcement of Copyright; Technology and Other Mechanisms
- Personal Perspectives
- The Slashdot Discussion of SBCCI v.
Veeck (an
online citation from Findlaw), a case where the copyright of a firm
that constructs model building codes successfully enforced its
copyrights on the resulting Texas law, making it illegal for Veeck to
post the Texas building code rules on the Internet; Is Law
Copyrighted?
- Carlton Vogt's Ethics Matters column; Infoworld,
May 1, 2001; Downloading
Music: harmful to the artist, the recording company of neither?; an
interesting take on where the harm lies - or doesn't
- Law.Com's ip law area; an
article
on SDMI/Felton
- Owning the
Future: PB&J Patent Punch-up; Technology Review; May, 2001;
Seth Shulman
- A personal WWW site
discussing the "DAT Tax" -- the fees embedded in all digital media
and recording devices
- Plunderphonics;
an essay on the legality and ethics of sampling, by a commentator on
the general issues of home audio cassette taping and music making &
distribution, as described in The Cassette
Mythos
- The
Economy of Ideas by John Perry Barlow; wired, Issue 2.03; March
1994.
- An article from Atlantic Monthly; Who Will Own
Your Next Good Idea?; Charles C. Mann; September 1998. An extremely
lengthy, extremely extensive discussion of the state of copyright in
the digital age, with historical exposition of the development of
copyright. Part
2 of the series starts with a discussion of James Brown and song
sampling, going next to Richard Stallman and the implications of
"Information wants to be free" and the legal and historical constructs
that support this - a discussion of the idea that copyright is a
bargain between the public and the author to bribe publishers into
disseminating ideas.
- Harlan Ellison's
ten year legal fight
against electronic copying and dissemination of his work on Speculations; see their Rumor
Mill section on Internet
Piracy for other comments by other authors, pro and con
- The
Real Slim Shady; Dylan Tweney; Mar 3, 2001; an opinion piece of the
relevance/irrelevance of copyright law in the Internet age
- Something from the EFF Archives: IAAL:
Peer-to-Peer File Sharing and Copyright Law after Napster; Fred von
Lohmann; again, the
Slashdot discussion
- Copyright enforcement; what it takes. Copyright
Laws Provide Little Protection - a small software developer makes a
mistake
- The Internet Society's
archive
on copyright
- The Law Office of Kelly F. Ryan has an Entertainment
and Music Law Resource Center
- What happens when the cost of digital access changes?
Here's one
story from kuro5hin
Some commentaries on digital culture
- A review
of republic.com
from the NYTimes
- Pay
to play is the Web's new mode; Patti Hartigan; Boston Globe; May 2,
2002
- Free
Rides Now Passe on Information Highway; Saul Hansell; NY Times, May
2, 2002; a slashdot
discussion
- Why
Open Content Matters; Bryan Pfaffenberger; Linux Journal,
Currents #30; April 11, 2001 - a discussion of the role of freely
exchanged information in an open society; nice URL bibliography
- An article from CNN Online; Thomas
Jefferson's moose and the law of cyberspace; David G. Post; August
8, 2000. A metaphorical look at the implications of going to a "new
place" and the effort to overcome the natural response
- Paulina Borsook's view; Cyberselfish
in Mother Jones on technolibertarians; Cyberselfish
Redux; the book that
grew out of it, with reviews; a fan's
compendium of all of Borsook's work
- Eric Raymond,
author of The
Cathedral and the Bazaar and the maintainer of fetchmail;
to get a flavor of his views, check out his writings page
- A little Salon byplay between Eric
Raymond and Paulina
Borsook over an article from the New York Times by Michiko
Kakutani
- A review
in Atlantic Monthly of Lawrence
Lessig's Code
and Other Laws of Cyberspace (ISBN:0465039138); note in
particular the reviewer's discussion of the fact that Lessig's worst
case scenario will not obtain because of what the users want and will
work to achieve; Lessig's WWW site has some funky javascript that makes
it really hard to read his articles online, at least on my browser.
Turn off javascript in your browser preferences and you'll probably do
a lot better. You can find his testimony on Napster, DVDs, and
Microsoft by selecting the "Testimony" link.
- The Berkman
Center for Internet & Society at Harvard; William Fisher's www
site for his course, Digital
Music: Problems and Possibilities
- Jonathan Zittran's argument about the relationship between
privacy protection and intellectual property defense; What
the Publisher Can Teach the Patient: Intellectual Property and Privacy
in an Era of Trusted Publication
- Why
Radio Sucks; why people might want Napster instead?
- Against
Intllectual Property; Brian Martin; from his online book Information
Liberation; Freedom Press; London; 1998.
- radiohead site
- Another copyright controversy - "The Wind Done Gone" - Dan
Gillmore's Copyright
tempest over 'The Wind Done Gone' is outrageous -
SiliconValley.Com; Lawrence
Lessig's take from the NY Times Op Ed; April 30, 2001
- Frankly
My Dear ...; William Safire's take on the Find Done Gone ruling;
NYTimes, May 14, 2001
- A brief statement of Lessig's thoughts about copyright and
the way that code in the digital world changes the world view - Lessig
- Opening Remarks; Second
Remarks and Concluding
Remarks from an intellectual
property roundtable run by The Atlantic Monthly based on Charles
Mann's Who Will Own Your Next Good Idea? (see below)
- Students
Rave About PC Music; Wired; April 13, 2001; Brad King - Students
prefer to use their PCs instead of their stereos for listening to music
(?)
- Truth
Squad Needed to Combat Internet Lies, Commercialization;
SiliconValley.Com; Dan Gillmore; May 8, 2001
- A Slashdot Discussion: Information
Wants to Suck, based on the following two provocative articles:
|
|
| Napster Case |
- Napster
- Some of the Players
- The Anti-Napster Positions
- Several songwriters who retained their copyrights sue
MP3.com - Tom
Waits dogs MP3.com for $40m
- The
Engine of Free Expression: copyright on the Internet; the NMPA's
position paper on digital copyright on the Internet - (with section
headings like "The Myth of Free Information" and "The Rationalization
of theft", this is a pretty strong position)
- RIAA positions; 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 - their legal filings
- SDMI - Secure Digital Music Initiative (this has really
flamed up over the last couple of days - probably merits its own
section at this point!!) - RIAA description;
defeat of protection "contest"; claims of defeat;
counterclaims; a technical
paper by the DE
SDMI research team; Felton's
Report, which the RIAA tried to suppress(the legal letter
requesting this suppression is part of this this link); the Slashdot
Discussion; a writeup of the threats on MSNBC - Music hack draws legal
threats (also with a nice little timeline of fair use in the
industry); the CNN
article on the effort to suppress Felton et alia's work
which includes links to the earlier articles on the SDMI Challenge; a report
that Felton's group withdrew the paper; the slashdot
discussion; the
Wired writeup(here's a local
copy of the paper in question); a nice
summary from SiliconValley.Com; another Wired article;
a commentary from Salon - Is
the RIAA running scared?; the Slashdot
discussion of this new interpretation; a NY Times commentary Doesn't
an Anti-Piracy Plan Quash the First Amendment?; Cryptome.org, who first leaked the
draft Felton paper circulating the WWW and still have copies online
- Here's Microsoft's version of SDMI - MS
May Have File-Trading Answer; OTOH, given MS's past performance in
this area, don't hold your breath - but thay *are* trying!
- SDMI is an implementation steganography - the
incorporation of data into another datastream that "cannot" be detected
easily - here's
a slashdot discussion
- From The Register: Napster
ponders Microsoft as technology partner: like, by using the Windows
Media Player format? Also, an article
from the LA Times; the Slashdot
discussion
- The GEMA
Chairman's Newsletter Column: Milestones in
the fight for author's rights in the digital world; attacking the
hardware side, rather than the copyright side;
- Artists
Against Piracy's WWW site; an interview
with the founder, Noah Stone
- Even more aggressive supporter site: www.stopnapster.com
- If you haven't been there yet, there's Copyright.Net, an internet
watchdog; a report
on what they do; another
report that explores the downside of using a crawler to ferret out
piracy; the Slashdot discussion of
Copyright.Net
- Did Napster kill a Grammy Single? The National Academy of
Recording Arts & Sciences' press
release on the suit; An article
from the Register
- "Pro-Napster" Positions
- The Technological Fallout - Mechanisms Developed To Further
An Agenda
- Music biz
backs anti-Napster MP3 sniffer-outer - a Register article about Songbird - "software that helps music
copyright owners ... find out how their music copyrights are being
infringed in the on-line world." - here's a Wired article on the
subject; Songbird:
Big Huff, Small Puff
- Napster
Software Will ID Sound; NYTimes, May 8, 2001; AP Wire Feed; the
article from The Register - Napster adds
audio fingerprint filter code
- The Cult of the
Dead Cow, a hacker group that made a big splash with their Back
Orificie security tester/cracker program, has some plans - "No
limits" browser planned
- A Slashdot discussion of a leaked (possibly real)
hardware spec for an encrypted monitor; Digital
Display Encryption Details Leaked; not clear that anyone will buy
if they have a choice, but here's at least an indication that someone
is thinking about "CPRM for video"
- Web
piracy crackdown spawns stealth platforms; MSNBC; Reuters Wire
Service
- Authentica says
they can figure out how to make you pay for each viewing; see this
Techweb article - Companies
Look to Put Content Under Glass; the Slashdot
discussion
- A discussion of the strike-counterstrike mentality
developing in the technical community; Web
Piracy-Crackdown Spawns Stealth Platforms; a Slashdot
discussion
- Napster
licenses acoustic fingerprinting technology; SiliconValley.com;
4/20/2001; the Slashdot
discussion
- How interesting! Microsoft's next version of Windows is
going to do a really bad
job of handling MP3s, favoring formats that are less open; the Wall Street
Journal article; the SiliconValley.Com
article; the slashdot
discussion
- Here's an article from the NY Times discussing the
Real/Microsoft rivalry in the media player space; Digital
Players Create Fury; NY Times; April 24, 2001; AP Wire
- A Slashdot review of
Peer To Peer, the book and the subsequent discussion
- From Salon: Who
Is Spying On Your Downloads?; the Slashdot
discussion
- FairTunes.Com - a
WWW site set up to enable one of the alternative models of artist
compensation - the online Internet "tip" - voluntary payment system -
they also maintain a news and discussion archive on the area and topics
within it.
- pay the band...
not the man! Another tipping service with online statistics
- An article from The Register about a Secure PC
- i.e., one that won't allow copying of copyrighted content.; the MS research
link describing the effort
- See also: Hardwiring
Copyrights from cNet News
- The much rumored International
Federation of the Phonographic Industry - IFPI Media Tracker
gets a report here on The Register
- A scare
piece from Wired describing how the technologies for making
Internet business models work represent potential challenges to or
invasions of individual rights
- An article
from The New Scientist on
Peer-to-Peer Networking, describing alternatives to Napster and
comparing their capabilities
- Security
Issues in peer-to-peer; from Wired
- Technical
discussion of bandwidth implications of Gnutella as an alternative
distribution model
- CPRM (owned by the 4C entity), ATA T.13 specification; revised submission with
comments; The Register's CPRM FAQ
& archive; What does
this mean for the general purpose computer?; update - the revised
CPRM specification fails to make
the ATA spec; a slashdot
discussion of the consequences; a legal article on the subject - Thieves
R Us by Mike Godwin of the EFF
- The Techno-fixes; a Newsweek article - Playing Fair With Copyright
by S. Levy
- Macrovision
technology applied to CDs - SafeAudio;
the Slashdot
discussion; a little
history
- InTether,
another techno-fix;
- DeCSS controversy
- DeCSS continued: the appeals process starts;
- GNUtella (and a
commentary, the Gnutella
Paradox, on Salon), OpenNAP etc; MojoNation; Bertelsmann deal;
subscription services; encrypted services (e.g., Filetopia)
- Another variant; Aimster
which encrypts all traffic, merges the concepts of Napster and AOL's
Instant Messanger and has a very interesting set of Terms of Usage; and article
on the terms which points out the following ironic feature of this
system:
Aimster encrypts everything that is moved around its network, including
all files and directories. It is impossible for anyone outside the
system to monitor the network without circumventing the security.
Breaking the encryption is illegal under the DMCA because the network
and its programming code are copyrighted.
This leaves copyright owners such as the music and movie industries
unable to access the network to monitor the traffic without first
breaking the very law they helped get pushed through Congress in 1998
A smart-aleck variant from AIMster - the Aimster Pig Encoder;
the emerging business
model for Aimster; Aimster
agrees to pull their pigencoder; Catnap as
a replacement
- AIMster takes the offensive with the RIAA; Aimster
sounds off in Napster's wake; the Wired
writeup; the Slashdot
discussion; from the NYTimes, May 7, 2001 - Compressed
Data: Copyright Rules Get Another Challenger; File Tracker
May Go Too Far, from Wired
- Another list of
p2p clients
- Something Napster has added to the mix; instant
messaging and targeted marketing to users of their system; P2P hard
disk snooping
- Yet another variant - ETC
Music; setting up MusicTellers to develop digital music
distribution tied to sales of MP3 players and the development of
personal lockers of music files purchased from ETC Music; as yet, not much RIAA buyin, yet....
- MojoNation -
another sharing variant
- Taking Napster Offshore?; an article from The Globe and
Mail, March 5, 2001; Napster
clone may set up shop offshore by Steven Chase; (a PDF version); the Principality of Sealand; HavenCo; the initiative site
- The Slashdot discussion
on the use of CDDB by Napster to aid file blocking; a commentary
by Brian Profitt on LinuxPlanet
- A Salon series entitled: Escaping the Napster Trap, Part
1 and Part
2; DivX as another open source technology for media delivery, this
time movies; can copy protection and open source co-exist? The movie
industry's take on what the record industry did wrong is instructive.
- A new technological variants - Audiomill, whose BitBop tuner
software automates time shifting of and searching for Internet radio
content; a
Salon article on Audiomill
- Freenet, a
variant whose developer has a
clear agenda to wipe out copyright - see this Newsbyte
article
- Digital
Giants Eye Napster's Market; maybe Microsoft and RealNetworks will
work a deal?
- An article
at Salon about Share Sniffer; another P2P variant that exploit a
common Windows security flaw, leaving Windows File Sharing enabled
while online; a standard NETBIOS attack that has other potential
applications
- Public Opinions
- A Slashdot article with comments: Napster,
MP3s & Burning CDs
- Here's a taste of the current opinions; a Slashdot
discussion in response to a question about how to
find a pro-Napster speaker for a high school in Indiana
- Copyright
Clash Shutters Speech(also
here); Brad King; Wired; May 2, 2001
- A little offtopic, but with some use statistics; Aimster
Pumps Up the 'It' Girl; Aparna Kumar; Wired; May 2, 2001
- The
American crocodile that swallowed freedom; John Naughton; April 29,
2001; The Observer
- An online satirical movie - MP3 the
Movie; a writeup
- A dangerously simplistic discourse on the ethical
questions, as posited by InfoWorld columnist Carlton Vogt: Is
downloading musing stealing? Napster tests our notion of right and wrong
- The Future of
Music site and their
manifesto promoting a new look at the relationship between artists
and distribution
- An editorial at FindLaw; Bringing
People Into the Copyright Arena: How the New Awareness of Copyright Law
Issues Can Help in Guarding the Public's Domain; Marci Hamilton
- A New York Times article on the tensions exposed by the
Napster technology; Musicians
Press Point on Online Rift; a related
discussion from the Los Angeles Times
- A personal perspective on the way in which Napster-like
tools get used; Paperback
Music; One Solution to the MP3 Debate
- A Salon article on the Napster "teach-in" ; Don't
March For Napster
- ; Andrew Leonard
- One way to read the public's pulse; the Comic Strips; even more interestingly, other people are paying
attention!; Slate's Napster
Editorial cartoon Index
- NYTimes; Feb 23, 2001; Art's
Cold Welcome on the Web; Paulina Borsook
- An Article from TheNation.com;
Liberation
Musicology
- A Dan Gillmor opinion piece at SiliconValley.Com; Hollywood
Putting the Squeeze on Consumers; March 3, 2001 (a PDF version)
- Napster
Fallout: Privacy Loses?; Jeffrey Benner; Wired; March 6, 2001
- Napster
Loss Is Copyright Gain; Brad King, Wired; March 3, 2001; Copyright:
Your Right or Theirs?, Brad King, Wired, Jan 19, 2001
- An article from the Detroit Free Press; Music
Industry won a battle, not the war; Doron Levin, Mar 6, 2001 (a PDF version)
- Bertelsmann chairman's prediction: Labels
to Work With Napster; from Wired
- Atlantic Monthly articles
- Robert X. Cringeley
Columns
- A Couple Of Points On Why People May Not Like the Record
Companies
- Something that confuses me personally - the Apple Rip. Mix.
Burn. ad campaign (the long
version - QuickTime 4 required to see them online). Think about it
- although there is an explicit difference here, doesn't it seem that
the "Burn" part can be switched to "Share" ?? Here's an
article on the advertisments from Slate. And here's an
article from Feed on the digital culture fallout and implications
from this.
- Apparently, making digital copies is not the only threat to
the industry. They are also out to stop the publishing of home-made
tablatures (fingering maps for people who want to learn how to play
songs). See Howard
Sacks talks about RenegadeOLGA.com dispute with NMPA; more from the
site itself; the Slashdot
discussion
- Some Archival Lists on the Controversy
- Music copying/taping in the pre-Napster era; The Grateful Dead, their free taping
policies; and the culture that has sprung up around it; The Deadlists; Resources
for Tapers Dead List; The
Grateful Dead statement on MP3s;
- News Archives
- Microsoft
Is Set to be Top Foe of Free Code; NYTimes; May 3, 2001; John
Markoff - interesting in light of Lessig's view of the role of Open
Source in terms of preserving Internet freedom; a
Slashdot discussion; a Salon article - Microsoft:
Free-software licenses are the devil's work
- This
is not your Founding Fathers' Copyright Law; Overprotective; Laura
Hodes; The New Republic Online; Dec 8, 2000
- Call
It The Digital Millenium Censorship Act; Unfair Use; Julie
E. Cohen; The New Republic online; May 23, 2000
- NYTimes; April 18, 2001 - Post-Napster
Musicians' Unlikely Ally: A Songwriting Senator; Laura Holson
- NYTimes; April 16, 2001 - New
Economy: Curdled Musical Romance Gets Couples Counseling; Matt
Richtel
- Napster Trial Followup - Judge Patel Threatens Napster - from
Wired; the
SJ Mercury Report
- Fallout from the Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing of
April 3, 2001
- Announcement of MIT's OpenCourseware Initiative; NYTimes;
the MIT
factsheet
- Wired; Napster
'Teach-In': Hail Shawn; the teach-in in advance of the Judiciary
Committee Hearings (see above)
- Metallica
Complains: Napster's Failing; from ZDNet News
- Congress
Again Cool to Napster; from Wired
- Another copyright controversy - freelancers and publishers
contesting ownership of material in digital form; the Slashdot
discussion
- From BBC News: Record
Industry Attacks Napster Filter; the RIAA wants and opt in filter
for Napster; the
Slashdot discussion
- From AustralianIT - Restricting
DVDs 'Illegal'
- Wired; Napster
Says It;s All Confused; Mar 21, 2001 - the lists, the filenames and
the ownership don't seem to add up
- The Register; March 16, 2001; Napster
filter cuts downloads by half; in Wired, the count is more like
60%; Napster
Sharers Sharing Less; the
Slashdot discussion
- Another fallout of DMCA; Slashdot
and the Removal of Scientology Stuff
- NYTimes; Aug 31, 2000; Taking Sides in the Napster War
- "cuckoo's eggs" and other activities
- NYTimes; Feb 12, 2001; Court
Rules Napster Users Infringe on Copyrights
- NYTimes; Feb 13, 2001; Napster's Business Rivals Celebrate
- NYTimes; Feb 13, 2001; Fighting
Free Music, Europeans Take Aim at Personal Computers
- NYTimes; Feb 13, 2001; Other
Music Swapping Services
- NYTimes; Feb 14, 2001; Envisaging
the Industry as the Loser on Napster
- NYTimes; Feb 16, 2001; Legal
Expert Sees Light Focused on Napster
- NYTimes; Feb 22, 2001; Math
Behind Napster Gambit Doesn't Add Up
- NYTimes; Feb 23, 2001; Legal Expert Sees Napster Competitors
Thriving
- Boston Globe; Feb 24, 2001; Moral Divide Over Napster
- NYTimes; Feb 25, 2001; Napster
Said to Hurt CD Sales
- Newsweek; Feb 26 issue; Playing Fair With Copyright;
Steven Levy
- SiliconValley.com; Feb. 27, 2001; Software
hunts for bootleg tunes on user's drives; Dawn Chmielewski (pdf version)
- NYTimes; Feb 28, 2001;Advocates
campaign against copy-protection plans; J. Borland, C-Net News.com
- NYTimes; Feb 28, 2000; Now That We're Here, Where Do We
Go? 7 Answers; the Napster discussion on page 13 forward is
particularly notable, as a discussion of the e-business perspective on
the controversy
- NYTimes; Mar 2, 2001; Fans
undaunted by Napster constraints
- Boston Globe, March 13, 2001; My torrid love affair with Napster;
Renee Graham
- Wired; April 12, 2001; Publishers
Set to Pile on Napster
- Who's next?? Gnutella in the MPAA's sights;The
C|Net article; the Register
article;Slashdot
discussion; the ZDNet
article and discussion
- Napster
blamed for falling music sales; the recounting of an IFPI press
release, done with a little more care than the treatment of the RIAA
release; Boston Globe, 4/21/2001
- NYTimes, APril 23, 2001 - Record
labels Struggle With Napster Alternatives
- NY Times, April 24, 2001; Napster
clone pushes new, ad-based service
- NY Times, April 25, (News from AP); Free
Web Music Sees Traffic Boom
- Copying
Styles, Stealing Rifs; Wired; April 26, 2001; Jason Silverman; an
argument that, for many mysic forms, copying is intrinsic to the
process of innovation
- Music
downloads have gone mainstream; SiliconValley.Com, David
Plotnikoff; April 25, 2001
- Napster judge
disappoints record industry; The Register; May 1, 2001
- Napster
Judge Utterly Frustrated; Wired; AP Wire
- RIAA Head:
Napster Is Done; Wired, May 2, 2001; Brad King
- Study
says Napster use down since blocking songs began;
SiliconValley.com; May 2, 2001
- Did
Napster Take Radiohead's New Album to Number 1? - mp3.com - this
merits checking out - are the allegations true?
- Net's
Big Role in Hollywood; Wired presentation of AP Wire report; May 7,
2001
- The EFF's Open
Audio License; the slashdot
discussion
- Other stuff: Microsoft: Prizes for
Rat Finks; the slashdot
discussion
- With the MS push to tell us about the evils of open source,
here comes Linus Torvalds to put
in his own two cents - the start of a nasty fight, methinks;
although there's really something a lot deeper going on, as Lessig's
book Code explains; here's one perspective
with a bunch of links to the start of the dynamic; a slashdot discussion
of a followup editorial; an article from The Economist - An
Open and Shut Case, May 10, 2001
- Doesn
an Anti-Piracy Plan Quash the First Amendment? - NYTimes; April 27,
2001; Questioning
Continues in Copyright Suit
- The PETA Controversy - Does
a Parody Site go Too Far?
- A rant
of my own
|
|